This weekend saw the running of two classic local fell races, Flower Scar and Midgley Moor. Calder Valley Fell Runners’ triumphed with men’s and women’s team wins and fantastic individual placings. Alex Whittem and Stephen Hall were 3rd and 4th at Flower Scar. At Midgley Moor, Bill Johnston lead his team mates down to the finish to gain joint 2nd place with Aaron Roberts and a M50 win, whilst Charlotte Jackson and Racheal Beaumont were 3rd and 4th women.
Flower Scar Fell Race.
Described as classic South Pennine racing, Flower Scar combines steep climbs, rough moor and fast paths. There are unmarked sections requiring navigation and contrary to previous years, there were no early starts, meaning only those confident of meeting the cut off times and having sufficient navigation skills dared to enter the AM category race, with 13.3km and 660m of climbing. 189 runners took up the challenge setting off from Todmorden cricket club on Saturday morning, among them were 10 hardy Calder Valley Fell Runners.
Alex striding out at Flower Scar. Photo credit Mick Fryer
Alex Whittem was the first Calder Valley runner to finish and 1st M40 overall with a time of 1:07:46; Stephen Hall was close behind with 1:08:26. Lee Shimwell ran further back, pacing his race knowing there was a tough final climb – his strategy paid off and he managed to squeeze into the top 10 on the last downhill with a time of 1:15:38. This gave Calder Valley the men’s team prize. George Kettlewell was placed a commendable 23rd after recovering from a fall on the penultimate descent. For the women, Calder Valley’s Amanda Farrell FV60 came first in her category with a time of 2:01:01. For Sam Hartley it was also a race of firsts, her 1st race for Calder and her 1st after the birth of her daughter last year.
Sam enjoying being back on the fells. Photo credit Mick Fryer
The overall race was won by Chris Holdsworth (unattached) in an impressively fast time of 1:02:37, smashing the existing course record.
Lee high above the valley at Flower Scar. Photo credit Woodentops.
Lee Shimwell reported that, as advertised, there were sharp climbs and fast downs, but that this year the clear weather meant the route choices were fairly easy. Other runners commented on the relentless mud and bogs, but the overall consensus was that the race was well organised by Todmorden Harriers and that ‘Tod Almighty’ is a fantastic February running venue.
Also of note was that this year the event aimed to be carbon neutral – the organisers calculated CO2 emissions from participant’s transportation, which will be offset by buying trees from a forest company that works with event organisers to make races as environmentally friendly as possible.
Flower Scar Results
Position
Competitor Name
Category
Time
3rd
Alex Whittem
MV40
1:07:46
4th
Stephen Hall
M
1:08:26
10th
Lee Shimwell
MV40
1:15:38
23rd
George Kettlewell
M
1:19:51
52nd
Kieran O’Prey
M
1:28:46
57th
Jake Smallbones
M
1:29:10
70th
Mark Wharton
MV55
1:30:41
160th
Tony Steward
MV65
1:52:33
175th
Amanda Farrell
FV60
2:01:01
182nd
Samantha Hartley
F
2:04:12
Midgley Moor Fell Race
Sunday saw the small but perfectly formed Midgley Moor take place. The 5-mile romp has been held annually for more than 20 years in the valley, organised by Calder Valley Fell running club and based from Booth Cricket Club and Midgleys Farm. With a surprising amount of up and down, it’s 1250ft of ascent make it a ‘Category A’ fell race. Local Calder Valley runners were out in force, making up 20 of the total field of 100 runners.
Bill leading out the young guns at Midgley. Photo credit Mick Fryer
Bill Johnson and Aaron Roberts were the first men home for Calder Valley, coming in joint 2nd overall and only 10 seconds behind the lead runner in a time of 47:39. Behind them was a stream of red and white as George Kettlewell and Paul Haigh took joint 3rd with a time of 47:52 and Lee Shimwell finished 7th place with 48:15. This meant the men’s team prize was secured for the 2nd time this weekend. Extra kudos to George and Lee, who after running impressive races at Flower Scar the day before, decided to stretch out their legs by sprinting round Midgley Moor.
Happy faces after great fun at Midgley. Photo credit Gloria Ayuso
Not to be outdone Calder Valley women were on top form; Charlotte Jackson continued her strong start to the year by placing 3rd woman and Rachael Beaumont took 4th to secure the women’s team prize for the club, Rachael was also first W50.
Midgley Moor consists of 6 checkpoints. Runners must visit each checkpoint in order but are free to choose between fast runnable trails or more direct lines yomping through heather. Over the short distance your choice of line can make or break the race as there is little time to make up for errors. This year more ever proved an example of this.
A very determined looking Aaron on the climb out of the valley. Photo courtesy of Andy Smith
Calder Valley’s Paul Haigh took the initial lead, with Bingley’s Paul Crabtree tucked in behind. Several other Calder Valley Runners were also well placed during the early stages of the race, with Paul leading and Aaron Roberts, Lee Shimwell, George Kettlewell and Bill Johnson all in the top 10 at the halfway point. However, on the way back Paul took a poor line across the moor, losing several minutes and leading the five runners behind him astray. This was the chance for Bill, in 7th place at that point, to take a better line and move into the lead. The group of runners behind Bill followed him. On the final descent, one of the group, Dave Parton of Rochdale, sprinted ahead to take the win, with Bill joint second along with Aaron – who had got so frustrated at being led astray that he flew down the final fields in the fastest split time of the day to make up for it.
Annie Hassell from Wharfedale was never troubled as the first woman, finishing more than a minute clear of the next woman in a time of 00:54:21, an impressive performance in a field that was notable for the number of female runners- 30 out of the 100 strong field.
Further down the pack finding the correct line was a tricky issue for all and various techniques were used to make up time. Andy Wright opted for gravity and mass in an attempt to overcome Oli Beaumont’s cunning use of the direct line from Sheepstones, while George Kettlewell put his faith in the older generation choosing to follow Bill Johnson’s perfect line for a 4th place finish ahead of his club mates.
Winning team at Midgley (2 women & 2 men to count) along with Race Organiser Bob Howard. Photo credit Gloria Ayuso
It seems the lesson from Midgley was experience, knowledge and great running ability will always win the race – as surely it should.
Midgley Moor, small and perfect with a friendly atmosphere, valley runners out in force and local support provided – there was even a free bottle of Midgleys milk at the end for all runners.
Calder veterans continue run of English Champs success
Will 2023 be another ‘golden year’ for CVFR? The new English Championship series has begun, and Calder Valley were out in force at Long Mynd Valleys, hoping to build on the club’s triumphant 2022 season.
The Long Mynd Team. Photo courtesy of Charlotte Jackson
This week also saw plenty of other racing successes for CVFR at home and abroad. Andrew Worster won the ‘in-betweener’ M35 category at Windy Hill (and third place overall), Stephen Smithies showed heroism worthy of the Milk Tray Man, and Jonathan Emberton won a V60 trophy in the mountains of Alicante.
Karl leads veterans to a strong season start
The annual English Fell Running Championship sees hundreds of the country’s top fell-runners battle for glory over a series of six races. Individuals and club teams score points based on their best four results, which must include at least one counter at each distance – short, medium and long. All the fixtures are tough category ‘A’ races, so competitors will encounter gruelling climbs, breakneck descents and plenty of gnarly terrain along the way.
Last season, CVFR took home gold medals for both men’s and women’s veterans teams, while Karl Gray, Gavin Mulholland and Math Roberts also notched up individual podium places. Hopes were high then, as 15 red and white vests headed to the Shropshire Hills on Saturday for the first 2023 English Championship counter, the 11-mile Long Mynd Valleys race.
Martin making it look easy. Photo Courtesy of Charlie Leventon
Martin Howard was the first Calder runner to finish, his time of 1:36:53 earning him 13th position. After being pleasantly surprised at feeling so strong on the course’s final three climbs, Martin said that he couldn’t have been happier with his first race of the year.
King Karl powering round the race
Meanwhile, CVFR’s Karl Gray and Gavin Mulholland – M50 gold and silver medallists respectively in the 2022 Championships – showed no let-up in their racing form. Not only did Karl win 1st M50 at Long Mynd Valleys, he came in ahead of all the M40 runners, taking 20th place overall in 1:38:51. Team-mate Gavin took 2nd M50 and CVFR’s Stephen Morran was 2nd M65. Ed Hyland had a fantastic run to be the third counter on the day for the men’s open team.
A strong start for the CVFR ladies team. Photo courtesy of Cass Chisholm
CVFR’s women also made a strong start to the new season. Susannah Richardson and Natasha Butterfield, both key players in their 2022 F40 team victory, were joined in Shropshire by club-mates Stella Chrisanthou, Cass Chisholm and Helen Curtis. Susannah was first of the team to finish, in 2:09:57, just over a minute ahead of her sister Natasha.
Matlock’s William Cartwright was the overall winner in a fiercely competitive field that saw the top six runners all break the previous course record. With good conditions on the day, and fell-running’s elite all striving for an early lead in the Championship tables, the women’s course record was also broken by winner Phillipa Williams of Dark Peak.
Official team rankings had not yet been published at the time of going to press, but our initial analysis of the results suggests that CVFR’s veterans won first place in both the M40 and M50 team categories, with the F40 team placing joint second. The men’s open team placed a strong fourth or fifth.
Long Mynd Valleys CVFR results
Pos
Name
Time
13th
Martin Howard
1:36:53
20th
Karl Gray
1:38:51
28th
Ed Hyland
1:40:45
34th
Gavin Mulholland
1:41:43
39th
Ben Mounsey
1:43:08
44th
Matthew Roberts
1:44:19
78th
Shaun Godsman
1:50:55
93rd
James Logue
1:55:35
98th
Virgil Barton
1:56:41
167th
Susannah Richardson
2:09:57
173rd
Natasha Butterfield
2:11:16
216th
Stella Chrisanthou
2:20:10
224th
Cass Chisholm
2:21:25
225th
Stephen Morran
2:21:33
270th
Helen Curtis
2:39:49
A haul of winnings at Windy Hill
The Windy Hill fell race is as almost as fast and furious as the motorway its course straddles! Runners pass under or over the M62 no fewer than four times as they make their way from Saddleworth to Blackstone Edge and back via the Windy Hills (there are in fact several tops in the area that share this name).
The event’s new hill-top location, the Ram’s Head Inn in Denshaw, meant that competitors got off to a flying downhill start, but had to reserve sufficient energy for the final climb back up to the pub from Piethorne reservoir.
Andy and Aaron with wind in their sails. Photo courtesy of Sam Hartley
There were five CVFR runners in a line-up of 219 competitors. Team-mates Andrew Worster and Aaron Roberts were neck-and-neck as they flew down the first descent, but Andrew pulled away over the 12-mile course to take third place overall, and 1st M35 – an age category not often used in fell races, but a well-earned result nonetheless, in a time of 1:23:10.
And all because Smithies loves Milk Tray. Photo courtesy of Francis Wooff
Andrew and Aaron were joined by fellow CVFR runner Stephen Smithies to form the winning men’s team. Completing the Calder gang’s enviable haul of prizes, Stephen also won 1st M55, earning himself a large box of Milk Tray – just in time for Valentine’s Day!
Matlock’s Harry Holmes was the overall winner, finishing in 1:17:04.
Windy Hill CVFR results
Pos
Name
Time
3rd
Andrew Worster
1:23:10
15th
Aaron Roberts
1:34:38
20th
Stephen Smithies
1:37:58
80th
Anthony Costello
1:55:41
137th
Francis Wooff
2:09:05
Veteran Emberton’s victory in Valencia
Jonathan brings back a souvenir from Spain
Calder Valley’s Jonathan Emberton took his red and white stripes to Spain for the Pedregeur Mountain Trail Race, on the Alicante coast near Valencia.
The rocky course demands maximum concentration, as well as physical endurance, over its 9 miles with 2,500 feet of climbing. Jonathan finished 1st M60, in 1 hour 50 minutes, and was rewarded for his efforts with an impressive-looking trophy.
With 7.5 million viewers tuning in to see Catherine Cawood’s and Tommy Lee Royce’s final showdown in Happy Valley it seemed that all eyes were very much on Calder Valley this weekend. And there was no shortage of dramatic plot twists during a busy weekend of running, with highlights including the Wadsworth Trog and the Todmorden Mini Mountain Marathon. It was a busy weekend too for the CVFR Juniors too, with a number taking part in the West Yorkshire Schools Cross Country in Leeds on Saturday.
The Wadsworth Trog
CVFR runners in high spirits at the start of the Trog
Affectionately known by locals as ‘The Beast’, the Wadsworth Trog is one of the highlights of the Calder Valley racing calendar. It clocks in at just under 20 miles, with an overall ascent of 3,624 feet and it is well-known for presenting runners with incredibly challenging conditions. Participants were relieved that the weather conditions on the day were much better than the 2022 race, but the terrain was still incredibly challenging with energy sapping bogs and plenty of tussocks to be stumbled over throughout the course. Calder Valley Fell Runners were well represented as usual – 18 hardy souls donned the red and white stripes on the day.
Andy looking comfortable at the Trog. Photo courtesy of Woodentops
The first of these over the line was Andy Ford who finished in 5th place overall in a time of 02:47:52. Andy was delighted with his result, which was one place higher than last year and saw him knock 11 minutes off his personal best. Andy described the race as “enjoyable though punishing” and has already committed to being back for more next year. He was quick to acknowledge the great support he received from various club members who were supporting the race and marshalling the various checkpoints.
Natasha on her way to taming The Beast. Photo courtesy of Woodentops
Natasha Butterfield was the first of the CVFR ladies cross the finish line in a time of 03:18:33. Tom Adams of Ilkley Harriers was the overall winner of the race in a time of 02:29:06 and Emma Hopkinson of Wharfedale Harriers won the women’s race in a time of 03:01:46.
Other highlights on the day included a great two-way battle between CVFR teammates Ben Frechette and Lee Shimwell. A quick start saw Ben take an initial lead, but Lee managed to reel him back in on the climb up to Top Withens and gain the advantage. But things changed again on the ascent to Lumb Falls as Ben regained the lead in their personal duel, and this time there was no catching him. With such keen competition it’s no surprise that this resulted in PB times for both runners. Ben finished in 16th place with a time of 03:05:16 and Lee secured 19th position, with a time of 03:10:58.
A number of CVFR runners were also taking on ‘The Beast’ for the first time. Charlotte Jackson was a little worried that she had bitten off more than she could chew, bearing in mind that her longest run to date had only seen her run 15 miles the week prior. That makes it all the more impressive that she tamed ‘The Beast’ with apparent ease, securing 66th place (of a total of 142 runners). Charlotte acknowledged that she was unfamiliar with the route, but had the pace to keep up with those just ahead of her, and relied on their navigation skills to keep her on track! Charlotte advised afterwards that the good weather made all the difference (having experienced getting lost in the mist when she took on the Half Trog at the end of last year). She shared: “The views on offer were incredible and it seems a shame that we didn’t get the chance to stop and fully appreciate them.”
And it was the first fell race in CVFR colours for James Mountain and Maxie Scheske. Similar to Catherine, they had first hand of experience of veering off course in the mist of the Half Trog, so were delighted to have managed to stick to the route this time around, and perhaps more importantly as James added: “not drowned in the bog!”
Full CVFR results
5th
Andy Ford
02:47:52
16th
Ben Frechette
03:05:16
19th
Lee Shimwell
03:10:38
31st
James Mountain
03:16:08
36th
Natasha Butterfield
03:18:33
43rd
Danny Seal
03:22:09
48th
Phil Wells
03:25:11
49th
Toby Cotterill
03:25:27
59th
Kieran O’Prey
03:32:03
60th
Maxie Scheske
03:32:18
66th
Charlotte Jackson
03:38:04
78th
Stuart Russell
03:44:51
92nd
Helen Buchan
03:55:47
97th
Oliver Beaumont
03:57:36
113th
Claire Hanson
04:10:01
123rd
Francis Wooff
04:33:39
128th
Andrew Meek
04:49:41
134th
Johnnie Watson
04:55:3
Todmorden Mini Mountain Marathon
Tamsin reaps the rewards of her success
CVFR’s Tamsin Cooke delivered a great performance this event – a three-hour scoring run with runners required to visit a series of controls dotted around Mytholmroyd. Tamsin was the first woman to reach the finish line. The route takes in a bit of everything that the local terrain has to offer, with different stages involving running through woods, navigating glens and streams, as well as the traditional trip across the moors. Tamsin managed to finish the route with six minutes to spare (avoiding any penalty points for exceeding the three hour time limit). Tamsin shared that she made a new friend on the way around: “I had a close encounter with a hare in Erringden Moor, so I told myself that was a good omen. And that’s exactly how it turned out.” Bill Johnson also showed his map reading skills by placing 3rd overall.
West Yorkshire Schools Cross Country
While CVFRs were contending with mud and bogs at the Trog our juniors had fast racing conditions at the West Yorkshire Schools Cross Country in Leeds on Saturday. After qualifying to represent Calderdale Schools we were well represented across most of the senior school year groups.
Harry setting a good pace. Photo courtesy of Rachel Cliff
In the Year 7 boys’ race Harry Cliff raced hard in this highly competitive age group to take 8th spot and to earn himself a place in the National Schools Cross Country. Harry’s team mates excelled too: Torsten Stephenson was 28th, Arlan Wiggins 35th with Ewan Edwards in 42nd place.
Clara on her way to another impressive win. Photo courtesy of Woodentops
Dominating the combined year 8/9 girls race was Clara McKee showing her athleticism to take a well-earned top spot and with her Calderdale team mates the junior girls won the team prize. Thomas McKee showed great strength and speed to get 8th place in the year 10/11 intermediate boys’ race. Both the McKees have qualified for the National Schools Cross Country race as well. Elijah Peers Webb, who’s been combining his running exploits with studying for his mock exams, ran well to take 14th place in the year 12/13 senior boys’ race.
In brief
CFVR runners were also busy outside of the Calder Valley. Ian Maher took on the Rombalds Stride, which is a 23-mile route that takes in some of Yorkshire’s finest scenery, going up the Airedale Valley, over Rombalds Moor to Ilkley and across Otley Chevin. Ian completed the race in 04:33:40 which was a top-half finish in a field of 400+.
And Jason Williams was representing CVFR in the Charnwood Hills Race in Leicester. This is a 14-mile race that is managed by Bowline Climbing Club. Results haven’t been published at the time of going to press.
The last Saturday in January, in the local fell running diary, is almost completely taken over by ‘the race that is not a race’ which is ‘The Hebden’. With no places available on the day itself the 500 entries for this race sell out like hot cakes within 24 hours of them opening and months before the race. Maybe that should read like hot ‘pies’ as this is one of the many delicious mid run snacks provided by volunteers at various check points.
This incredibly popular jaunt around our local hills and trails has a real party feel to it. In fact, many runners contend it is ‘the’ way to kick off the year in style. With two separate routes available: a 15 mile version and for the braver souls the full 22 mile route, there really is something for everyone.
As usual, registration opened at 6am and long before the sun even began to stir. At sun rise around 8am the runners then set off from the Saint Michael’s church hall in Mytholmroyd. Around 4.30pm as the sun set, they had until the event finish at Mytholmroyd’s Shoulder of Mutton pub, to get round their chosen route. The very fastest run the full 22 miles in an astonishing sub three hours.
Chris on bis way to the win on the 22 miler. Photo courtesy of Mark O’Connor
Race organizer, Gareth Baigent, and his amazing team of 50 volunteers yet again made sure the whole event flowed like clockwork. This included everything from registration, manning checkpoints, helping a runner with a broken bone down to get first aid and feeding runners at various checkpoints. Competitors do get through a lot of food! There was still more than enough to spare, with those who stayed until the end going home with the excess provisions, including tiger bread, bananas, almond milk and, of course, bags of pies!
After a two-year hiatus, the red and white hoops were again out in force, with scores of CVFR club members taking on one of the two routes. This year runners were exceptionally lucky with the weather which bucked recent trends. It was not only beautifully dry but even spring like. This added to the feeling of this being just a big club social, rather than a competitive event, where serious runners from a whole range of clubs pit themselves against each other.
Team Kelly at the start
CVFR husband and wife Raymond and Penny Kelly decided to run together. Raymond was quick to describe how great it was to see so many competitors at the start line at day break and how amazing it was to be rewarded with such a stunning sunrise on the first ascent up to Midgley.
It was Penny’s first time running in the red and white stripes and she really enjoyed the relaxed atmosphere, which felt like ‘just a sunny morning run in the sun and having a chat’ for much of it. At the end, however, she joked that ‘the highlight’ was definitely when she realised she didn’t actually have to run right up to Stoodley Pike as she had assumed and ‘with just a couple of miles to go at that point this was a very pleasant but welcome surprise!’
Great team mates Susie and Layla working hard together on the 22 miler
Reflecting back on the day, Calder Valley’s Laura Green commented on how ‘the miles just disappeared’ as she ran about ‘chatting and eating’ with friends around our beautiful valley. Fellow red and white striped runner and first timer at this event Charlotte Jackson commented on how it was a ‘lovely to see so many familiar faces and catch up with so many people both during the run and for the food afterwards at the pub’. Jackson described it as ‘a wonderful morning out with the CVFR gang’, but also some ‘strong running all round’, which included her taking 7th place in the women’s race.
And despite the fun atmosphere there remains more than a little serious running for those who take part to compete against each other or themselves! Whilst results had yet to be published on going to press Calder Valley’s Catherine Holden ran a storming race to take 2nd lady in the 15 mile event & Stella Chrisanthou came fast on her heels in 3rd. Susannah Richardson and Layla Hirst ran strong as a team in the 22 miler. Susanne ran round the route with a very sore toe which later turned out that she had lost her big toe nail. Us fell runners do like to look at photos and share our feet stories. Helen Buchan ran one of her best in the 22 mile race getting a sub 4 hour under her belt for the first time and taking 5th lady.
Happy Hyland looking strong. Photo courtesy of Mark O’Connor
In the men’s event, there was a real battle for the top spot between CVFR’s Ed Hyland and Chris Holdsworth in the 22 miler. The latter took first place in ‘perfect running conditions’ and was particularly thankful to the former for pulling him back when he set off in the wrong direction a few times! Hyland was delighted with his podium finish having decided to give it full beans this year. He was incredibly pleased to achieve both of his goals for the race in keeping Chris Holdsworth in sight and getting round the 22 miles in under three hours. Hyland was over the moon to cross the line in 2hr 52mins, mere minutes after clubmate Holdsworth, although he did wonder what might have been if he hadn’t stopped at all the check points for juice and jelly babies!
Thumbs up. A happy looking Chris at the finish
And not to be outdone another top spot for the red and whites as Chris Hall came away with the win in the 15 mile route. Another great club day was had by all.
By the end of the day, a lot of fun had been had by all and arguably most importantly, the money raised on the day will ensure that The 12th Halifax Sea Scouts have much needed funds to provide life changing activities for young people aged 4 – 18 years and beyond.